Govt’s housing reform bill sparks pension investment concerns

The Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Governmentt’s Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill has sparked concerns about its potential impact on pension investments.

The government said the reforms were the biggest shake-up to home ownership in 100 years, aiming to give leaseholders more power over their homes.

Changes in the bill include capping ground rents at £250 a year from 2028, and reducing ground rents to zero after 40 years.

However, Real Estate:UK assistant director, Kate Butler, said it was “disappointing” that the government had pushed ahead with the cap, describing it as disproportionate and warning that it could impact up to £12bn of legitimate investments, including people’s pensions.

“Reforms must fairly balance the rights of leaseholders and property investors,” Butler stated.

“A proposal that cuts across existing commercial arrangements, raises the risk premium attached to the UK, and undermines its investment reputation, at a time when the government is seeking to attract capital for its growth agenda, does not achieve this.

“Instead, the government must work towards a pragmatic solution that identifies and addresses the few ground rents that affect owner-occupier leaseholders, while preserving legitimate investments and the UK’s reputation as a place to invest.”

The decision to adopt a 40-year sunset on zero ground rates rather than the proposed 20-year timetable was a “significant concession” that vindicated concerns raised, said Justice for Property Rights spokesperson, Richard Merrin.

However, he warned that the policy remained a “deeply damaging” intervention in legitimate property rights and investments.

“The government is proposing to rewrite the terms of lawful, long-standing contracts, transferring substantial value away from investors who acquired these assets in good faith,” Merrin said.

“These include small-scale investors who historically invested in ground rents as a source of pension income. The consequences will extend far beyond the freehold sector.”

Merrin also raised concerns that the reforms would not be beneficial for attracting investment in the UK.

"At a time when Britain desperately needs investment in housing, infrastructure and economic growth, ministers are sending an extraordinary message to domestic and international investors: assets acquired legally in the UK can have their value fundamentally altered by subsequent political decisions,” he added.

Merrin also warned the government of the potential legal consequences of the reforms, taking the view that, unless the government provided a detailed impact assessment of the 40-year cap, thousands of small-scale investors would be seeking at least £20bn in compensation.

"Ministers may believe that a 40-year sunset has settled this debate. It has not. Parliament must now examine the full economic consequences of these measures, including their impact on pension funds, savers, institutional investment and the future financing of Britain's housing stock,” he concluded.



Share Story:

Recent Stories


Exploring the role of real assets
Pensions Age Editor-in-Chief, Francesca Fabrizi, joins Nuveen Real Assets Head of Strategic Insights, Abigail Dean, to explore the role real assets can potentially play in pension fund portfolios

AI and the future of UK pensions
Laura Blows speaks to Scottish Widows’ pensions expert Robert Cochran, about the growing role of artificial intelligence (AI) in the UK pensions industry

Supporting retirement decisions
Laura Blows discusses retirement saving levels in the UK, and the support required for members, trustees and employers, with WEALTH at Work director, Jonathan Watts-Lay

Pension risk transfer partnership
Podcast: From pension pot to flexible income for life

Advertisement Advertisement