Small pots consolidation offers 'once-in-a-generation opportunity'

The government's proposed small pension pots consolidation framework offers a "once-in-a-generation opportunity" to tackle inefficiencies in the pensions system, but industry organisations warned it must avoid unnecessary costs and complexity while prioritising member outcomes.

Responding to the Department for Work and Pensions' (DWP) Small Pots: a pathway for consolidation consultation, The Investing and Savings Alliance (TISA), the Association of Professional Pension Trustees (APPT), People's Pension and Lumera broadly welcomed the proposed Multiple Default Consolidator model, but stressed that its success would depend on effective governance, robust safeguards and the use of existing industry infrastructure.

The proposals aim to automatically consolidate eligible deferred defined contribution (DC) pension pots from 2030, addressing the growing number of small pots created as workers move between employers.

People's Pension chief operating officer, Angela Staral, described the reforms as a "once-in-a-generation opportunity" to address one of the biggest inefficiencies in the pensions system.

However, she argued the industry needed to look beyond consolidating existing small pots and develop a long-term solution that supports secure, efficient, low-cost transfers at scale.

"There has already been significant progress in modernising transfers, so much of the technology needed for this is in place," she stated.

"Rather than developing costly new systems, success will depend on creating the conditions for industry coordination through common standards, strong governance, and a clear implementation roadmap."

Staral also stressed that implementation costs should be minimised and must not fall disproportionately on other pension scheme members.

Echoing these concerns, TISA welcomed the government's proposed model, noting it offered a practical, competitive approach to consolidation while avoiding the risks of relying on a single consolidator.

However, it warned that adopting a closed or proprietary transfer system could restrict competition, limit consumer choice and undermine innovation.

TISA head of policy, products and long-term savings, Renny Biggins, said: "Consolidating the millions of small pension pots is an important step to improving the outcomes for pension savers, and getting the transfer system underpinning this process right will be integral to its success.

"If we don't, we risk pension savers paying the price for costly and complex pension transfers."

Biggins called for an open standards approach that builds on existing infrastructure and can evolve alongside the wider savings and investment landscape.

Meanwhile, Lumera welcomed the government's support for a scheme-led federated model operating within centrally governed standards, arguing that existing industry capabilities should be reused wherever possible.

Lumera commercial director, data and dashboards, Maurice Titley, said: "The consultation takes the federated model an important step closer to delivery. The priority now should be to build on proven industry capabilities, with strong central governance and common standards, rather than recreating functions the market can already provide."

Titley warned that the proposed central digital interface should have a clearly defined role, with schemes, consolidators and providers continuing to undertake matching and transfers through secure, interoperable systems.

He also highlighted the importance of balancing automatic consolidation with meaningful member choice, particularly given that the reforms are primarily intended to benefit disengaged savers.

"Get that balance right, and small pots consolidation can reduce fragmentation and provide a much stronger foundation for Guided Retirement," he concluded.

Alongside concerns about infrastructure and costs, the APPT backed the proposed consolidation framework, provided members' rights were protected, and trustees had clear, objective decision-making rules.

APPT Legislation and Regulation Committee deputy chair, Tova Docherty, supported an initial focus on default arrangements within large AE schemes, with expansion following testing.

"Member disengagement does not diminish the value of guarantees," she warned.

"Schemes should confirm that protections will be preserved or members have made an informed choice to relinquish them. Material, irreversible or hard-to-quantify losses should normally exclude pots from automatic consolidation without informed member choice."

The APPT also called for a safe harbour against retrospective challenges where trustees and scheme managers followed prescribed processes in good faith, while maintaining accountability for breaches of legal duties.

It supported the proposed 30-day notice period and two communication touchpoints, but emphasised that member communications must clearly explain the consequences of inaction, including any changes to charges, investments or existing protections.

In addition, the association called for standardised procedures where communications fail to reach members, alongside robust data standards and administrative safeguards.

Its pensions partner, Ferdy Lovett, welcomed the government's proposals but warned that requiring trustees and providers to exercise discretion over individual transfers could create disproportionate costs and administrative complexity.

"The success of the solution will depend on how far it can genuinely be made automatic," Lovett suggested.

"Legislation should set clear rules for preserving guarantees or protections when small pots are consolidated, while giving transferring schemes an appropriate safe harbour where they comply with their duties."

Lovett also called for small-pot consolidation to be included in the government's planned expansion of protections for members transferring pensions.



Share Story:

Recent Stories


Exploring the role of real assets
Pensions Age Editor-in-Chief, Francesca Fabrizi, joins Nuveen Real Assets Head of Strategic Insights, Abigail Dean, to explore the role real assets can potentially play in pension fund portfolios

AI and the future of UK pensions
Laura Blows speaks to Scottish Widows’ pensions expert Robert Cochran, about the growing role of artificial intelligence (AI) in the UK pensions industry

Supporting retirement decisions
Laura Blows discusses retirement saving levels in the UK, and the support required for members, trustees and employers, with WEALTH at Work director, Jonathan Watts-Lay

Pension risk transfer partnership
Podcast: From pension pot to flexible income for life

Advertisement Advertisement