At Morrisons' AGM on 11 June 2020, some 34 per cent of the listed company's shareholders voted against its latest triennial remuneration policy. Perhaps this was not surprising given the company pension contributions for two directors were almost five times that of the 5 per cent for the general workforce.
The Investment Association (IA) red flagged this issue, and Morrisons itself acknowledged its proposal did not meet corporate governance concerns.
Two important issues arise: first, the legal context of the relevant corporate governance rules and, secondly, in relation to a company's pension scheme, the potential impact of non-compliance with corporate governance rules.
Corporate governance
Morrisons applies the UK Corporate Governance Code (the Code). So far as pensions are concerned, the Code specifically states that only basic salary should be pensionable and that "pension contributions for executive directors should be aligned with those of the workforce."
The IA's latest Principles of Remuneration state that investors expect new executive directors, or directors changing roles, to have the same rate of contributions as the general workforce and that for incumbent executive directors, the contribution rates should be reduced to the workforce level as soon as possible, and from 2020 there should be a credible action plan to achieve this by the end of 2022.
Morrisons' approach
Morrisons' annual report and accounts to 31 December 2019 acknowledge that, in relation to two incumbent directors, Morrisons needed to make further reductions in the employer's rate of pension contributions over the life of the new remuneration policy. So Morrisons was not in compliance with the Code, but its report and accounts acknowledged this as the Code requires.
However, the IA's corporate governance arm, Institutional Voting Information Services, red flagged Morrisons' pensions contribution policy, and the slowness of its reduction, and advised institutional investors to vote against the policy.
Although 34.8 per cent of investors did so, 65.2 per cent of shareholders voted in favour and the resolution passed. In recognition of the significant minority vote, Morrisons is compelled by the Code to address shareholder concerns and its remuneration committee has committed to continue discussions with investors.
As 65.2 per cent of shareholders voted in favour, one could regard the outcome of the AGM as little more than a storm in a teacup. However, it may harm relationships with a range of stakeholders, including the trustees of the company’s defined benefit scheme.
Excessive executive remuneration and pensions
The Pensions Regulator (TPR), in its Annual Funding Statement issued on 30 April 2020, expressed its general concerns in respect of covenant leakage. Put simply, this means money distributed by the company and potentially leaving the company with insufficient monies to meet its pension funding obligations. Hence TPR's preoccupation with dividend and other company distributions, including what TPR calls "excessive executive remuneration".
Although those words are not defined, one can see that very substantial salaries and pension contributions paid to directors, or to some of them, could depending on the circumstances amount to excessive remuneration.
Should TPR look to investigate a particular company, a remuneration policy being contrary to corporate governance guidelines could be of particular interest to TPR. All the more so where the pension scheme is poorly funded and/or the employer's covenant is weak, and in circumstances where the employer seeks deferral or suspension of its deficit contributions to the scheme.
Companies also need to keep in mind that TPR's armoury of anti-avoidance powers is likely to be widened shortly. The Pension Schemes Bill contains proposed new criminal offences for actions which, in effect, strip the company cupboard bare so that it can no longer support its pension scheme. Having been held up by Covid-19 legislation, the Pension Schemes Bill is due to resume its progress through Parliament on 30 June 2020.
Reducing executive remuneration may be no easy matter for a company. Unlike dividends which are usually decided year-by-year, remuneration including pension contributions is set under an executive's contract of employment. Varying such contracts may well be difficult, and there is always the risk that a company loses talented leaders.
So in TPR focusing on what it may regard as excessive executive remuneration, TPR may undermine a company rather than sustain it. As TPR acknowledges in its April 2020 Annual Funding Statement, "the best support for a pension scheme is a strong employer".
Engaging TPR's interest is not easy. Pension scheme trustees themselves are closer to the ringside and arguably should seek to ensure the company complies with good governance requirements.
Conclusion
The importance of compliance with the Code and the IA's Principles of Remuneration was not enough for activist shareholders to defeat the Morrisons board position. However, to take a cynical view, the non-compliance may give another important stakeholder – scheme trustees with TPR in the wings – influence (for example, in funding negotiations) where a company has, contrary to governance requirements, disbursed excessive cash to executives rather than conserving it for the pension scheme.















Recent Stories