Autumn conference




The first choice for people in pensions

Pensions Age has been designed to provide pensions professionals with a single and authoritative source of information.




Court ruling offers greater protection against old negligence claims

1 August 2008

Pensions advisers have received a timely boost from a recent Court of Appeal ruling which will give them further protection against old negligence claims.

The recent Shore v Sedgwick Financial Services Limited case ruling, delivered at the Court of Appeal on 25 July, has effectively reinforced the two time periods during which an individual can apply for a claim of negligent advice. The rules state that if a loss is immediately apparent it can be brought up to six years after the event. Where a loss may not be immediately apparent, a claim must be brought within three years of the date the claimant became aware of the loss.

A damages claim bought by a Mr. Shore for negligent advice he received from Sedgwick in 1997, relating to the transfer of pension benefits in an occupational pension scheme to an income drawdown scheme failed as Mr. Shore missed out on taking action within both these time periods.

The ruling stated that the six year rule started to run from the date Mr. Shore made the transfer out of the occupational scheme. The Court confirmed that under the three year rule, time started to run out as soon as Mr. Shore had sufficient knowledge of a possible claim against Sedgwick to enable him to embark on the preliminaries of bringing a claim.

Gary Squire, pensions disputes lawyer at law firm Osborne Clarke, said that the ruling was a welcome one for beleaguered advisers who had seen a significant rise in claims against professional advisers in the pensions sector.

“This ruling will prevent some “old” claims based on advice given many years ago. These claims can be difficult to defend if documents are no longer available or if the advisers involved have moved on,” said Squire.

“The case also sends a clear message to claimants: as soon as you have inkling you might have a claim – act!” he added.

- Pensions Age August 2008

   
  top
 

 Back to news list